Whisler Edits Blog

3 Secrets Every Writer Should Know

3 Secrets Every Writer Should Know

October 20, 2021•9 min read

Discover in this post …

  • how mindset plays an essential part in your writing journey.

  • how to overcome an innate weakness all writers have in common.

  • how to ensure readers remember your story.


Internalize these basic tenets to elevate your writing and fortify your mind:

1. You’re doing yourself a disservice if you view writing in terms of success and failure.

Years ago, I drove almost an hour to attend my first writing critique session. I had researched the group and its leader beforehand, and I’d memorized the names of the attendees. On the passenger seat of my van lay a notebook and binder, a few pens, a handwritten list of Brandon Sanderson’s writing group rules (from his Writing Excuses podcast), and the prologue to my fantasy novel (which I later cut).

Physically, I was prepared.

But as I trekked up two flights of stairs to the library’s second floor, the foremost question on my mind was the wrong one.

Will they like my writing, or won’t they?

My heart beat twice its normal rate as I neared the meeting room. I clutched my notebook and binder, wondering if I would blurt out nonsensical words if asked to speak. No one but my family and a few close friends had ever read my writing.

That was my first mistake.

The evening passed without any great embarrassment. I learned some useful tidbits, met other writers, and managed to form full sentences in conversation.

But the age-old question that everyone tends to wonder now and then—“Will they like me?”—was detrimental in a way that took me years to understand.

Writing isn’t pass/fail.

The attitude that made me ask, “Can I be a writer or can’t I?” was just plain wrong.

You can do it if you want to. It’s as simple as that. (Just don’t mistake “simple” for “easy.”)

The Sorting Hat put Harry Potter in Gryffindor for one reason: because Harry chose it.

You can be a writer if you want to. You might struggle for years to finish your first novel, or pull your hair out when the ending you planned needs major revisions, or scream into a pillow when two weeks slide by and you still can’t figure out how to resolve that tricky plot twist.

But you can do it.

Writing is a conscious choice. Expect obstacles in droves—but you can face them.

If your work schedule changes and you can write for only thirty minutes every other day, then do that.

If you email query letters to two hundred agents and get two hundred rejection letters, you can self-publish. (You may want to self-publish anyway—there are a host of benefits that come with this choice.) Or you can bide your time and build your skillset. Or you can write another book.

Your mindset matters. Think about writing in terms of constant self-improvement rather than believing you’re “good at it” or “bad at it.” Every single person who wants to write a better book can do it. It will take sweat and dedication, but there is always something you can do to better your craft.

Whether you’re a beginning writer or a seasoned author, your book will never, ever be perfect. “Perfect” doesn’t exist. But “better than before” does—and that’s a goal that’s always within your grasp.

Nicole Whistler Book Editor + Coach

If readers tell you one of your characters is stale and boring, don’t despair. Fix the problem. Your readers are not critiquing you. They’re critiquing words on paper. And you hold the power to change those words. If you don’t know how, find some books on writing (like the ones listed on my Resources page), study like you’re in high school (an image that might not work for some of you, but I was that kind of nerd), and use what you learn.

I don’t have a terrific memory. Words don’t always flow effortlessly for me. I simply have a deep desire to write, and the ability to work hard.

That’s it.

So the next time you bite your nails and wonder whether you will succeed or fail as a writer, check yourself and ask the right question: “What can I do next to improve my craft?”


2. You need other people in your writing process—even if you think you don’t.

Every writer is different, but in one area, we all have the same weakness. You might write beautiful, descriptive prose. You might have a knack for creating unique characters. You might know just the right way to pack an emotional punch. You might have an IQ of 140.

But you are only one person.

You come from no one’s background but your own.

You see the world with your eyes and no one else’s.

If you’re in a writing group, maybe you can relate to the moment that plays out something like this:

Critique Group Member: “So…why is Benny suddenly able to talk with Erin so easily when on page four, he couldn’t even look at her without turning red?”

You (while blinking and scratching your head): “Oh. Um. Yeah. Good question.”

Because you didn’t think of it, that’s why. Because you are too close to your material. And while that’s exactly where you want to be while you’re writing—deep in the trenches—you need to poke your head out once in a while to take in the full terrain.

I used to be an acutely private writer. In my early teen years, I wrote an entire novel without telling my family. I turned my computer screen away anytime anyone entered the room while I was writing. (Why no one questioned me further about this, I’ve never asked.)

In college, I dated my boyfriend (now husband) for a full year without once mentioning I liked to write. Not because it wasn’t a big deal—but because it was the biggest deal.

This may have been a mistake. Or it may have been what I needed at the time. Either way, the day I first shared my material with my critique group was a day of vital progress.

Exactly when you reveal your work to others is up to you. You might benefit from support and encouragement while you’re writing. Or you might prefer to complete a first draft before letting anyone peek at it. Do what works for you. There is no “correct” timing or format for getting outside appraisal, as long as you acknowledge that at some point, you need to let others in.

Nicole Whisler Writing Coach

If you’re unsure how to do this beyond begging your family members to read your work, here are some starting points:

  1. Join a free in-person or online critique group through a website like Meetup or through Facebook. You can also ask your local library for suggestions. (Note: The type of writing group you join matters. You may have to try more than one to find a group that supports you and provides useful feedback.)

  2. Use beta readers and/or critique partners. You'll come across Facebook groups dedicated to beta reading if you look. Check out more options on Twitter, Instagram, and Goodreads. And again, don't underestimate the power of your local library.

  3. Pay to join a writing program (David Farland’s Apex Writers is a great example if you’re ready to commit). Research your options to find one that will benefit you most.

  4. Attend a writing conference. Look for one that fits your specific needs.

As a disclaimer, this piece of advice applies mostly to closet writers (as I used to be). Writers who fear venturing outside their comfort zone. Writers who turn up their noses as they tell themselves, Anyone who wants to change my writing must not understand my vision. But that might not describe you at all. If you’re on the opposite end of the spectrum—sharing your work at every opportunity—you may need to hear different words. To you, I say this: don’t ever discount your own voice as a writer. Don’t let anyone bulldoze you or your ideas. Select your writing community with care.

Ultimately, you may already be a talented writer. But you are limited to your own mind—no matter how brilliant a mind it might be. Seek out other readers and writers in the way that works for you, and watch as your writing grows stronger, sharper, and more riveting as a result.


3. Your writing may not live longer than the last page if you don’t express a conscious theme within your story.

Have you ever found yourself unable to remember if you’ve read a certain book? Or maybe you know you’ve read it, but your mind grows hazy when you try to recall a single event or character.

Producing forgettable material is a writer’s worst fear. Or one of them, anyway. Every word we write represents an arrow we aim straight at readers’ hearts. We want readers to laugh, cry, hold their breath, and revel in the journey.

When they flick aside our arrows, scrunch their noses, and grunt, “Huh?”, it devastates us. Because it means they didn’t understand what we were trying to accomplish. They didn’t connect with the story.

They weren’t emotionally invested in the book.

Nicole Whisler Writing Coach

This is not a reason to give up as a writer. This is an opportunity to examine why readers reacted this way.

It’s possible your arrow-flickers are not your target audience. If this happens, shrug off their indifference and find someone who regularly reads your genre.

But if you notice a pattern—if your novel doesn’t stick with people over time, despite its clean prose, exciting twists, and realistic characters—it may mean your story is missing its heart.

Heart is expressed through theme.

Contrary to popular belief, theme is not an elusive idea that winds itself through your story of its own accord.

Theme is purposeful, specific, and planned. Don’t confuse it with a preachy “moral,” like in a fable. In a classic "arch-plot" storyline, theme is conveyed through the fatal flaw of your main character and how that character changes over the course of the book. Take a conscious approach to theme, and readers will find meaning in your work. They will close your book with a deeper understanding of a universal human truth. Your story will resonate, and it will stay alive.

To learn step-by-step how to build your theme throughout your novel, check out my blog post that dives deeper into this topic and examines the way script consultant Dara Marks and screenwriter Eric Edson weave theme through story.

If you already knew all three of these “secrets,” you’re ahead of the game. Use what you know, seize every opportunity to learn, and go forth and write.


Can you relate to any of the three “secrets”? Are there others you would like to add? Leave a comment to let me know!


Do you want to learn how to write a story that makes your target readers stand up and cheer? If you’d like support from A to Z (from brainstorming to drafting to revising to publication), book a Discovery Call with me to see if you’re a good fit to join my book coaching program, Fantasy Footsteps: Road to Publication. And if you haven’t done so already, grab your Free Guide on how to hook readers from your story’s start!


Nicole Whisler Edits

Back to Blog

Ready to Get Started?

@2026 Whisler Edits. All Rights Reserved.